Skip to main content

More sport hours, same missing foundation: what 1,332 students tell us about fundamental motor skills

article spotlight
Students in sport-specialized PE programs outperformed their peers in traditional PE. Yet nearly three in four still fell below even an elementary level of fundamental motor skill proficiency.
Author

Ovande Furtado

Published

October 24, 2026

Abstract motion arcs in navy and slate with a single ochre accent.

Students who receive 10 or more hours of sport-focused physical education per week may still lack basic movement competence.

Article details

Makaruk, H., Webster, E. K., Porter, J., Makaruk, B., Bodasińska, A., Zieliński, J., Tomaszewski, P., Nogal, M., Starzak, M., Śliwa, M., Banaś, M., Biegajło, M., Chaliburda, A., Suchecki, B., Molik, B., & Sadowski, J. (2025). Assessing fundamental motor skills proficiency in school-based sports physical education programs: implications for talent development. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 7, 1632930. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2025.1632930 (open access)

Background and aims

School-based sports programs are commonly assumed to support talent development by increasing the volume of physical education. Whether this additional volume translates into broad fundamental motor skill (FMS) proficiency is less certain. Makaruk et al. (2025) posed two research questions: (a) whether sport-focused physical education (PE) programs are associated with higher FMS proficiency than traditional PE, and (b) whether the resulting skill profiles are more consistent with early specialization or with early diversification.

Method

The sample comprised 1,332 students aged 10–14 years (grades 4–8) from 12 schools across Poland. Approximately 550 students attended school-based sports PE programs, which provide at least 10 hours of PE per week with sport-specific training; the remaining students attended traditional PE (4 hours per week).

The authors measured FMS proficiency with the FUS test, a process-oriented assessment of six tasks: hurdles, jumping rope, forward roll, ball bouncing, ball throwing and catching, and kicking and stopping a ball. Each task was scored against five movement criteria, and students were classified into one of four overall proficiency levels: excellent, good, elementary, or insufficient.

Results

Students in sports PE programs scored higher than their traditional-PE peers on all six tasks. Nevertheless, overall proficiency in both groups was low. In the sports programs, 72% of boys and 77% of girls were classified as “insufficient,” that is, below even an elementary level; in traditional PE, the corresponding proportions were 90% of boys and 92% of girls. Only about 14% of boys and 6% of girls in sports programs reached a “good” or “excellent” level.

Skill profiles also differed by sport. Students tended to be proficient in the skills their sport rehearses and weaker in others. Soccer players performed best in kicking and stopping the ball (95% at mastery or near-mastery) but poorly in the forward roll and jumping rope. Basketball players led in ball bouncing. Track and field students were strongest in hurdles and the forward roll and had the lowest overall rate of insufficient proficiency, whereas volleyball players had the highest insufficient rates of any sport track.

The authors interpret these narrow profiles as evidence of early specialization rather than diversification: sport-focused programs appear to refine sport-specific skills at the expense of a broad motor foundation, contrary to the recommendations of sampling-based models of talent development.

Discussion and implications

For PE and talent development programs, the central result is that practice volume did not make up for limited breadth of movement experience: most students training 10 or more hours per week still lacked basic movement competence. Teachers should therefore assess FMS in sport-track students too. A student may appear skilled in a particular sport while lacking proficiency in entire movement domains, and a brief process-oriented assessment such as the six-task FUS test can reveal deficits that game performance conceals.

The results also support delaying narrow specialization and retaining varied movement tasks in the curriculum, particularly before age 14. Students who encounter a “proficiency barrier” early may have greater difficulty acquiring new skills later, regardless of sport. The authors link narrow early specialization to higher risks of burnout, injury, and dropout, the outcomes talent programs aim to prevent.

Limitations

The sample was drawn from a single country (Poland) and a single national program, so the results may not transfer directly to other school systems. The cross-sectional design provides a snapshot rather than longitudinal data, and therefore cannot show how these profiles develop or whether they predict later outcomes. Physical maturation, which influences motor performance at these ages, was not measured. Finally, proficiency was evaluated with a single assessment instrument, so the findings depend on the constructs that instrument captures.

Reference

The article is open access: Makaruk et al. (2025), Frontiers in Sports and Active Living.

A practical next step

For a practical way to assess fundamental movement skills, see FG-COMPASS, an assessment tool I developed for use in educational and clinical settings.


This post is a brief overview intended to help readers decide whether to read the full article. It is not a substitute for the original research. If you use these findings in your own work, please cite the original article.

Back to top